Mental illness and legal incompetence are not the same; it does not necessarily follow that all mentally ill people are legally incompetent. Competency certification is a procedure during a Baker Act that can be misunderstood and applied unfairly. Psychiatrists at a Baker Act receiving facility certify competence. What may not be widely known is that someone can be held under a Baker Act involuntarily, even if the patient is competent. There are two areas in which competency during Baker Act examination is certified: voluntary admission and consent to treatment. If a patient is certified as incompetent for voluntary admission, they cannot be competent to consent to treatment. If the patient is certified as competent and requests voluntary admission, he or she can be a “voluntary” patient, and there is no court hearing in which a facility psychiatrist must testify. There is no “72-hour clock” in which actions by the facility must be taken within the examination timeframe. Patients in voluntary status may be in a Baker Act receiving indefinitely. Requests to patients to accept voluntary status are so common that, in some facilities, the staff completes the request for voluntary admission form, except for signature, and calls it “signing voluntary.” Some patients are reportedly told if they sign voluntary, they will be released sooner. If a patient is not on voluntary status, however, the patient can be certified as either competent or incompetent. Competence does not mean agreement, but it may be viewed that way by Baker Act psychiatrists. In practice, if the patient agrees to medication, then the patient is viewed as competent; if not, then the patient is seen as incompetent merely because he or she is not cooperating with needed treatment. If the patient is certified incompetent, a proxy’s permission is sought for treatment until a court hearing is held. This is usually the same hearing for involuntary placement. At this time, a guardian advocate (often the proxy) may be appointed by the court. Now the guardian advocate’s permission is sought by the hospital – the same as permission from the proxy before the court hearing.
Related Stories
December 28, 2022
Reclaim your right to keep and bear arms. A conviction for a crime could prevent…
December 28, 2022
As a country whose constitution literally allows the right to bear arms to everyone, it’s…
October 13, 2022
We are heading towards a new world that infuses innovation with convenience. We are witnessing…
October 13, 2022
Legal matters are often complex and require help from a professional law firm. However, it’s…
October 6, 2022
The involuntary commitment laws in the Baker Act allow people to receive care in a…
October 6, 2022
The baker act allows doctors, therapists, and judges to commit a person to mental health…
October 6, 2022
Parents can use the Florida Baker Act for children with severe mental illness. The act…
October 6, 2022
The Baker Act allows family members to put some other person in custody. If they…
December 28, 2022
Reclaim your right to keep and bear arms. A conviction for a crime could prevent…
December 28, 2022
As a country whose constitution literally allows the right to bear arms to everyone, it’s…
October 13, 2022
We are heading towards a new world that infuses innovation with convenience. We are witnessing…
October 13, 2022
Legal matters are often complex and require help from a professional law firm. However, it’s…
October 6, 2022
The involuntary commitment laws in the Baker Act allow people to receive care in a…
October 6, 2022
The baker act allows doctors, therapists, and judges to commit a person to mental health…
October 6, 2022
Parents can use the Florida Baker Act for children with severe mental illness. The act…
October 6, 2022
The Baker Act allows family members to put some other person in custody. If they…